I need some book help, please read?

I know that a 12 year old is probaly not the age group of the audience you are trying to reach, but I actually quite like your ideas. They sound exciting, unpredictable, and very original. I always really like it when books are like that. My favourite is the second option because it sounds like you can really do alot with the story and it sounds fun to read and fun to write. The second one sounds the most realistic in a way though. I love the idea of her being mentored by a guy who knows something about angels. I can picture it all in my head already- it would make a great movie. I would love to be able to read a story like that.